Score: 9

"Nice!"

submission: MAC - Rise To Freedom

date: October 24, 2008

I too am participating in this Mac, but I promise to not let that change my thoughts.

This is a really great piece, it has an awesome relaxing quality to it. Perhaps if you ever got time, though, make it longer. That was the main problem I had with it, too short. The choir was a nice addition, I liked that.

Overall nice job on this, good luck for the competition.

5/5
9/10

Score: 6

"Again, same with the second part."

submission: cool beat1

date: October 24, 2008

It's essentially a really big loop with some really small changes, it would be better to shorten this down to a smaller loop. And for a song called 'cool beat', it lacks...a cool beat. Pretty generic Hip Hop stuff.

3/5
6/10

Score: 8

"Alright."

submission: Jewels of Malice: Part 7

date: October 24, 2008

I don't quite understand your descirption. Saxaphone solo? Am I retarded or what?
The shredding was pretty unrealistic (part of the magic of computers playing it for you) and you need to mix better, everything was at the same volume. Loud. So the sound started to get crackly.

Overall, pretty nice work, keep it up.

4/5
8/10

Score: 6

"Pretty good."

submission: cool beat2

date: October 24, 2008

Pretty good, but exceptionally repetitive. The whole thing was just a giant loop.
It would have been much better for you to just make a 30 second to 1 minute loop of this. It's alright, but needs improvement.

3/5
6/10

Score: 10

"Awesome!"

submission: Element of Dance - F-777

date: October 22, 2008

Great work as normal.

One thing that really appealed to me for some reason that I can't explain was the arpeggiated synth. It really had...a thing about it that reminded me a little of chiptunes.

This has a great beat, I was actually tapping my foot while listening to it. The melody was also awesome, it'll be in my head forages. Nice work again, awesome piece keep it up.

5/5
10/10

Score: 10

"Awesome!"

submission: Rig & Mihai - City Block loop

date: October 3, 2008

This is some good stuff!

The beats have a nice Hip-Hoppy style to them, same with the bass. Then, you add the trumpet and piano, and it gives it a sort of jazzy tinge. It's a great combination, and it fits the theme of the CTSG Collab well, just the sort of thing I was expecting out of the menu. It also loops really smoothly.

Congratulations on a great track, keep it up!

5/5
10/10

Score: 9

"Nice!"

submission: Never, Maybe, Forever

date: October 3, 2008

It seems you guys are the kings of ska here on NG. Now I know why.

This is a great track, sure the quality isn't the best, but you explained why in your description, so that doesn't matter. Otherwise, it was an awesome track. Keep it up, you guys!

9/10
5/5

Score: 9

"Holy crap!"

submission: MS - Madness Gun Sounds!

date: October 2, 2008

You sir, are awesome.

Despite the fact that it was just essentially a drum loop, it was a catchy, well put together, gunny loop.

With guns.

Great job. I can't explain exactly what I like to much about this, but ARGHH, it's awesome!

Great work, keep it up!

5/5
9/10

Score: 10

"Awesome!"

submission: St. Thomas - Sorohanro

date: October 1, 2008

Fantastic work with this.

I myself play trumpet too (though not nearly as well as you) so I can really appreciate the work you do.

Again, great track, everything was nice and clear, it never got boring or repetitive.

5/5
10/10

Score: 10

"Perfect."

submission: -Orr- Heroic Confrontation

date: September 14, 2008

This piece is the musical form of epic-ness, sharing the top spot with your other awesome piece, "Four Brave Champions".

I have to congratulate you on this piece, I wish I could write like you.

This piece makes a wonder addition to Sunny, great work, this is perfect.

10/10
5/5